Why Change Fails: Stalling Isn't One Thing
Based on the Lippitt-Knoster model of managing complex change.
The Scene
You keep trying to get something off the ground. The vision feels crystal clear to you. And yet it stalls: another restart, another round of "so what are we doing again?" The usual response is to say the vision louder, push harder, or add more urgency. It rarely works, because that only fixes one of the five things that can be going wrong.
The Trap
Treating "it's not working" as a single problem, and answering it with the one lever you already have.
The Reframe
Stalling isn't one thing. Change needs five ingredients together: vision, skills, incentives, resources, and an action plan. Take any one away and you don't just get a weaker change. You get a specific, recognizable symptom. So the symptom tells you what's missing, and you can fix that piece instead of pushing on everything.
The Matrix
Each row takes one ingredient away. The last column is what you get.
| Vision | Skills | Incentives | Resources | Action plan | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vision | Skills | Incentives | Resources | Action plan | Change |
| Missing | Skills | Incentives | Resources | Action plan | Confusion |
| Vision | Missing | Incentives | Resources | Action plan | Anxiety |
| Vision | Skills | Missing | Resources | Action plan | Resistance |
| Vision | Skills | Incentives | Missing | Action plan | Frustration |
| Vision | Skills | Incentives | Resources | Missing | False starts |
What each one sounds like:
| What you're seeing | What's missing | What it sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| Confusion | Vision | "Why are we doing this?" |
| Anxiety | Skills | "I don't think I can do this." |
| Resistance | Incentives | "What's in it for me?" Or a quiet, polite no. |
| Frustration | Resources | "I'd do it, but I don't have the time, tools or people." |
| False starts | Action plan | Lots of energy, then restarts and dropped threads |
How I Use It
I bring this into a working session when a change has stalled and nobody can quite say why. I open by saying stalling isn't one thing, then walk through the framework above and give everyone in the session a few minutes to take it in.
While they're absorbing it, we start unpacking it together. The goal isn't to find one big answer, and it isn't to swap it for one smaller answer either. It's usually a combination of factors. Someone will say "now that I see this, it's this one and this one," and that's the moment to point out.
Even when it's several things at once, the matrix breaks the problem down. "It's stalling and it's not working" turns into separate pieces you can name, and each piece gets its own plan.
Steps
- Name the symptoms you're actually seeing, not the ones you assume. Pick as many as apply.
- Match each one to its missing ingredient.
- Treat each ingredient as its own piece of work: clarify the vision, train or pair people, change what's rewarded, free up capacity, or write the plan.
- Check again. Fixing one often makes the next one visible.
Why It Works
It replaces a vague "people don't like change" with a diagnosis you can act on. Resistance in particular is often rational. It's what you get when the incentives don't line up, not a character flaw in the people involved.
How to Use This With Someone
Don't hand them the answer. Show the matrix, let them read it, and ask what they're seeing. Most people find they've been supplying the wrong ingredient, for example repeating the vision to people who actually lack the skills or the time.
Get new frameworks as they're added: follow on LinkedIn or RSS.